Social Security: Surprising Insights on How the Program’s Advantages Differ Depending on Income and Wealth

ayman022

Social Security is the foundation of retirement income for most Americans, but what it delivers, and how much it matters, can look very different depending on your financial situation.

Recent research highlighted by The New York Times shows that wealthier households often receive more lifetime benefits than lower-income households, largely because they live longer and can delay claiming. Yet for retirees with modest means, Social Security remains the single most important financial safety net — one that makes retirement possible at all.

Let’s look at how the system works for two hypothetical retirees.

Maria earned about $45,000 a year throughout her career. She contributed to Social Security from every paycheck and retired at 65. Her benefit is about $1,800 per month — not lavish, but predictable and inflation-adjusted.

For Maria, Social Security provides:

Stability: It covers most of her housing and basic living expenses.
Protection: The benefit increases each year with inflation, something few private pensions or savings accounts can guarantee.
Longevity insurance: She can count on the payments for as long as she lives — even if her savings run out.

If Maria were to buy the equivalent lifetime income from a guaranteed lifetime annuity with 5% inflation protection, it would cost around $450,000 today (this is a way to approximate the lifetime value of her Social Security benefit). Her benefit represents a large proportion of her overall wealth in retirement. And with it, she has the security to plan her monthly spending and enjoy a modest but confident retirement.

Without Social Security, Maria’s savings would likely be gone within a few years.

Explore 11 ways to retire on Social Security alone.

David spent his career earning around $150,000 a year and was able to save aggressively in his 401(k). Because he earned more and worked longer, his Social Security benefit will be about $3,700 per month if he claims at 70.

For David, Social Security is less about survival and more about strategy. The payments provide:

A guaranteed income stream: Even though he doesn’t depend on it, Social Security adds stable, inflation-protected income to complement his investments.
Longevity hedge: Delaying benefits provides protection later in life, when he might prefer to draw less from market accounts.
Tax coordination: By balancing withdrawals from his savings with Social Security income, he can reduce taxable income and preserve portfolio longevity.

David’s lifetime benefits are likely to exceed Maria’s in dollar terms. The equivalent lifetime annuity would cost $750,000 even though it is paying out over a shorter period of time than Maria’s. And, proportionally, Social Security replaces a much smaller share of his working income. For him, the benefit is one of several pillars; for Maria, it’s the foundation.

See the highest possible Social Security benefit and how to qualify.

What These Two Stories Show

Social Security delivers value across the wealth spectrum, but it does so differently:

Income Level	Role of Social Security	Key Planning Focus
Lower income	Core income source, safety net, inflation hedge	Timing of claim, budgeting for essentials
Higher income	Supplemental, stabilizing income stream.	Tax strategy, withdrawal sequencing, longevity planning

The key takeaway? Social Security is not one-size-fits-all. Your benefit depends on when you claim, how long you live, and how it interacts with your other resources.

The Social Security benefit formula is progressive — lower earners receive a higher percentage of their pre-retirement income. But lifetime wealth still plays a large role in total benefits received.

People with higher incomes:

Tend to live longer, which means they collect benefits over more years.
Often have a spouse who also qualifies for benefits, increasing household payouts.
May delay claiming until age 70, locking in higher monthly payments.

In contrast, lower-income workers often claim earlier and may not live long enough to benefit fully. The result: lifetime Social Security income ends up higher for wealthier households.

Taxes and Savings Interact with Benefits

Another factor is how Social Security interacts with other sources of income. Retirees who draw from savings, pensions, or part-time work may owe taxes on up to 85% of their Social Security benefit. Those with limited income may pay little or no tax at all.

This doesn’t mean the system is unfair — but it does underscore how important it is to think about how and when you withdraw income in retirement. Smart tax planning can help you keep more of what you’ve earned.

If you’re building your retirement plan, here are a few takeaways:

Model your Social Security claiming options: The difference between claiming at 62 and 70 can mean hundreds of thousands of dollars over a lifetime. The Boldin Retirement Planner lets you see those trade-offs clearly.
Plan your withdrawals strategically: Coordinating Social Security with IRA or 401(k) withdrawals can help minimize taxes and make your income more reliable over time.
Account for longevity: If you expect to live well into your 80s or 90s, delaying Social Security can provide valuable inflation-protected income later in life.
Build flexibility: Social Security is just one piece of the puzzle. The more adaptable your plan is — across savings, spending, and tax strategies — the more confident you can feel regardless of policy changes or personal circumstances.

Planning with Confidence

At Boldin, we believe the power of Social Security lies in understanding how it fits into your whole retirement plan, not just what it pays each month. Whether you’re building a secure base like Maria or optimizing a broader portfolio like David, clarity leads to confidence.

Use the Boldin Retirement Planner to: